Our first herbs arrive in January 2027. Join the waitlist

The Field Guide · 1.2

Part 1 · 1.2

Eight ways a herb gets faked

By THE HERB ITSELF · Updated

A close view of a ground spice powder
Powder is the easiest form to stretch with something cheaper.

Almost every fake falls into one of eight patterns. Each one below comes with a real, recorded example.

Eight ways, at a glance

A careful buyer can catch

1A lookalike plant
2The wrong part

Check the botanical name and the part.

Only a lab can catch

3Fillers
4Added colour
5Added weight
6Old or spent stock
7Hidden medicines
8Chemicals not allowed

Ask for a lab report for the batch.

1. A lookalike plant

A cheaper plant that looks the same is sold in its place. The Ministry of Ayush warns that Tinospora crispa looks like giloy and may be harmful (Ministry of Ayush, 2021). Three different plants are sold as shankhpushpi (Malik et al., 2011). See giloy and shankhpushpi.

2. The wrong part

The right plant, but a cheaper part of it. India now allows only ashwagandha root in foods and supplements, because leaves were being used (FSSAI, 2026). Some Kerala water mixes use sappan bark rather than heartwood (Down To Earth, 2020). See ashwagandha.

3. Fillers

Something cheap is ground in to stretch it. Saffron powder has been bulked with turmeric and paprika (American Botanical Council, via NutraIngredients). Fillers turned up in the 2016 DNA study of Indian herbal products too (Shanmughanandhan et al., 2016).

4. Added colour

Dye makes a weak or fake herb look rich. Researchers built a test for sappan wood dyed with Sudan III, textile dye or red yeast rice (Batubara et al., 2022). Synthetic dyes turn up in saffron powder (Heyrani et al., 2025). See sappan wood.

5. Added weight

Herbs sold by weight can be made heavier. Saffron threads have been coated with syrup, glycerin, olive oil or honey (Heyrani et al., 2025). See saffron.

6. Old or spent stock

Old or used-up material is mixed in with fresh. Older saffron is one recorded example (Heyrani et al., 2025).

7. Hidden medicines

A drug is added so the product seems to work. Ten of 58 Ayurvedic and herbal products tested in India held a steroid and a painkiller that were not on the label (Savaliya et al., 2009).

8. Chemicals that are not allowed

Not a swap, but a treatment the buyer never sees. In 2024 Hong Kong stopped the sale of four Indian spice mixes over ethylene oxide, a gas used to kill germs (Reuters, via Gulf News).

Patterns 1 and 2 are about the name and the part, so the label can catch them. Patterns 3 to 8 need a lab. How labs check.

This guide is for buying well. It is not medical advice. If you are pregnant, take regular medicines or have a health condition, talk to your doctor before taking any herb as a remedy.