Our first herbs arrive in January 2027. Join the waitlist

The Field Guide · 1.1

Part 1 · 1.1

Why herbs get faked

By THE HERB ITSELF · Updated

Hands grinding fresh leaves to a green paste on a grinding stone
Once a herb is ground, nobody can see what went in.

Most herbs are sold cut, dried or ground. Once a plant looks like that, it is easy to swap, stretch or colour, and hard for a buyer to tell.

How common is it?

In 2016, researchers bought 93 herbal products from ten companies in stores in Coimbatore and read their DNA. Only 40% were what the label said. The other 60% held plants that were not on the label: most had other plants mixed in, some had been swapped for a different plant, and a few were bulked with fillers (Shanmughanandhan et al., 2016).

That is one city and one study, not the whole market. But it is not alone. In a 2023 study of Brahmi products bought in the market, only about half tested positive for Brahmi (Shah et al., 2023).

What the tests found

4 in 10herbal products bought in Coimbatore were what the label said. The rest held plants not on the label.

Shanmughanandhan et al., 2016 (93 products, DNA tested)

About 1 in 2Brahmi products bought in the market tested positive for Brahmi.

Shah et al., 2023

Matched the label Did not

Why it happens

Mostly money. When a herb is popular and costly, a cheaper lookalike pays. The Brahmi researchers call it economically motivated adulteration, in a market that is growing (Shah et al., 2023). Saffron, among the costliest spices, is called one of the most widely adulterated botanical ingredients in the world (American Botanical Council, via NutraIngredients).

Names make it easier. One common name can cover two or three plants, so a seller can be honest about the name and still sell the wrong plant. More on names.

It is not only plants

  • Hidden medicines. A lab tested 58 Ayurvedic and herbal products from across India. Ten held a steroid (dexamethasone) and a painkiller (diclofenac) that were not on the label, and two more held one such drug each. All of them were sold by practitioners, not by manufacturers or chemist shops (Savaliya et al., 2009).
  • Chemicals that are not allowed. In April 2024 Hong Kong stopped the sale of four Indian spice mixes over ethylene oxide, a gas used to kill germs, and Singapore recalled one. The makers said their products were safe (Reuters, via Gulf News).

What you can do

You cannot read DNA at home, but you can ask the right questions. The next chapters show the eight ways a herb gets faked, how labs catch each one, and end with a checklist you can use in any shop.

This guide is for buying well. It is not medical advice. If you are pregnant, take regular medicines or have a health condition, talk to your doctor before taking any herb as a remedy.